Sonoma County supervisors on Tuesday achieved an arrangement to extend for three months a cap on the quantity of vacation rentals in the county, a significantly cry from the 22 months employees had sought.

The unanimous vote saved the ceiling for the variety of holiday rentals at 1,948 — the quantity of existing permitted rentals — until finally mid-December. The cap was adopted as an urgency ordinance that the board accepted Aug. 18 and that was to expire Oct. 2. The cap applies only to the unincorporated spots of the county, not its towns.

The Tuesday vote came about by a previous-minute compromise that overcame the objections of 3 supervisors who were being leaning from extending the cap at all.


Under the proposal fashioned by Supervisor Lynda Hopkins, the countywide restrict expires in December but at that time, county staff is to current a new proposal addressing only people areas of the county most impacted by holiday rentals, the Russian River and Sonoma Valley.

The board on Tuesday at very first appeared poised to reject totally on a 3-2 vote the proposal to prolong the cap.

“I want to aid you clear up your challenges inside all those unique regions in your district but I never imagine a moratorium and the extension of a moratorium is the respond to,” Supervisor David Rabbitt explained to Hopkins and Supervisor Susan Gorin, the board chairperson, whose district includes Sonoma Valley.

But one particular previous attempt by Hopkins — whose district features the Russian River communities of Guerneville, Forestville, Monte Rio and Rio Nido — to style a brief-term answer gained out.

“This is not a black and white problem,” she stated, responding to issues that the proposed cap could harm the neighborhood financial state, primarily the tourism sector, was unfair to unique assets entrepreneurs, and was a blanket solution to a difficulty impacting only selected parts of the county.

Both of those she and Gorin — whose Sonoma Valley district has the most trip rentals in the county — acknowledged that a countywide cap was an imperfect instrument.

“We do have a dilemma,” Hopkins explained. “How do we go about approaching that issue in a extra focused way.”

She explained the lessen Russian River as currently being once a location of vacation cabins and vacationing San Francisco inhabitants but that has advanced into a 12 months-spherical “live and do the job” neighborhood that is commencing to “erode” underneath the strain of holiday vacation rentals.

Gorin stated, “I’m not always supportive of this method, never have been, it can be an urgency system to deal with some of the problems … I would be wanting for a way to set a cap on individuals regions that we have determined briefly.”

A Saturday occasion at a vacation rental in Gorin’s district led to gunfire that hit 5 houses no just one was hurt.

But the other supervisors designed apparent they wouldn’t be on board with the countywide cap for much for a longer time.

“Coming back again, I’m not heading to be voting to hold my district in a moratorium. So it presents the time for you all to occur again with proposals for your districts, and I regard that,” reported Supervisor James Gore.

Supervisor Shirlee Zane mentioned, “I will compromise on this proposal until December but not earlier then.”

In proposing the extension, county workers pointed to elements including a 2015 report that concluded that the quickly rising number of family vacation rentals was cutting into the housing readily available for operating family members.

In opposition to that backdrop, considering the fact that the 2017 Tubbs and Nuns fires, which ruined 5,334 houses in Sonoma County, the amount of trip rental permits issued in the unincorporated parts of the county by yourself has risen by pretty much 45 percent, from 1,335 to 1,904, workers stated.

But Zane turned down the premise that holiday vacation rentals are notably impacting the housing current market.

“Perhaps a report we did six many years ago demonstrates it can be possessing an effects. But the major effects is that we all have to phase up and set on our political britches and say we want affordable housing, and we have to have to stand up to NIMBYs,” she mentioned.

The 2015 report manufactured 4 tips to regulate and cut down the affect of getaway rentals. 1 was to prohibit much more rentals in city places and demand permits that require approval in rural places. The other a few recommendations were being to allocate lodging taxes to economical housing programs, waive specified improvement fees, and make certain web sites that are ideal for housing are created prepared for progress.

Less than the ordinance, when a holiday rental permit expires other programs are allowed until the cap is reached all over again.

Copyright © 2020 by Bay City News, Inc. Republication, Rebroadcast or any other Reuse without the convey composed consent of Bay Town News, Inc. is prohibited.